• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Paranormal Pizza: Best Vegan Pizza & Wings in Bethlehem, PA

Paranormal Pizza in Bethlehem, PA, redefines vegan dining with bold, flavorful creations that satisfy all palates. Their standout dishes, like the Garlic Knot Pizza and Seitan Wings drenched in spicy Buffalo Sauce, offer rich textures and authentic taste that even non-vegans rave about. The Special Bacon Chicken Ranch and Smoking Man Pizza blend classic pizza elements with innovative plant-based ingredients, delivering savory, layered flavors. Customers praise the perfect balance of sauce, dough, and cashew cheese, making each bite memorable. Friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere complete the experience. Paranormal Pizza proves vegan food can be indulgent, exciting, and deeply satisfying.

Paranormal Pizza at a glance

  • Address 125 E 3rd St, Bethlehem, PA 18015, United States
  • Phone +1 484-357-8727
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Paranormal Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Andrew Lynn
5

Love this place! We were regulars for them in their old location and couldn't wait to check out the new place. Just as good as I remember. The wings are so good I forget I'm not eating chicken!

Elliot Nolter
5

Buffalo wings are excellent… texture, flavor, value. And the pizza is top notch! If I didn’t know it was vegan, I wouldn’t be able to tell the difference! Great atmosphere and service, too!

Jason Capobianchi
5

This is the best vegan pizzeria you will ever find! I drive over an hour to get food from here, no other place has made pizza and garlic knots as delicious as here! Just tried the cheesy bread last visit and of course didn’t disappoint at all! Been coming here for years and will continue to for years to come! The other options are also very delicious! The new shop is awesome, the staff are always awesome and very friendly! I promise they will never disappoint!

Dawn Soli
5

I was a bit skeptical if I would like this pizza since I’ve never tried cashew cheese before but the pizza overall was SO GOOD. Sauce, cheese and dough was perfect. The pepperoni was also not too chewy and a good texture and flavorful. I do wish they had more by the slice options. Only the cheese and pepperoni were available otherwise if you wanted something else you would have to buy the whole pie.

Tammy Artman
5

I love the garlic parm wings with ranch - - that's my favorite. The Detroit pie is a close second. The pork less sandwich, cheese steaks and smash burger are also good. You should definitely give it a try whether you are vegan, vegetarian or not.

frank williams
5

owner was very nice & knowledgeable. himself and staff were very hospitable to everyone who entered the restaurant the pizza had an amazing crunch & taste. & the Cheesesteak was AMAZING SOFT SOFT ROOL & GOOD FLAVOR. I WAS FULL FROM ONE SLICE & HALF OF THE CHEESESTEAK. BUT NOT BLOATED FUL. HIGHLY RECOMMEND

The Banker's
5

Paranormal Pizza isn’t just a vegan restaurant. Nope!!! It’s a place that wins everyone over. Whether you’re plant‑based or not, the food is bold, satisfying, and genuinely crave‑worthy. It’s the kind of spot you keep coming back to because it never misses. My husband and I constantly crave everything from their wings to their mouth watering chicken sandwiches. You simply have to give them a go!!!!!!!!

Turtle Badgie
5

Paranormal Pizza is an amazing 100% vegan pizza place but the pizza is not the (only) reason to go. The cheese steak is to die for. Super affordable and super huge portions. I got 3 slices thinking I could manage, they were all doubles! I barely finished 2. Staff is amazing and sweet, the vibes are immaculate.

Location

  • Paranormal Pizza
    Paranormal Pizza
    125 E 3rd St, Bethlehem, PA 18015, United States Hotline: +1 484-357-8727

Paranormal Pizza, nestled in the heart of Bethlehem, PA, is redefining the vegan pizza experience with bold flavors and impressive craftsmanship. This pizza haven invites both vegans and non-vegans to indulge in dishes that challenge traditional expectations, boasting a menu that's as innovative as it is delicious.

At the core of their offerings are standout items like the Garlic Knots and the Seitan Wings drenched in buffalo sauce—both delivering rich, satisfying textures that make you forget they’re plant-based. The Garlic Knot Pizza is a clever twist, merging the beloved bread knot with pizza toppings, creating a harmonious bite bursting with garlic and savory flavors. Not to be missed are the Italian Sausage and Smoking Man Pizza, the latter loaded with pepperoni, onions, peppers, and mushrooms, providing a complex medley that captures the essence of classic pizza with a vegan spin.

Customer feedback paints a vivid picture of the restaurant’s quality and atmosphere. Regulars speak highly of the wings, praising their authentic texture and bold buffalo flavor, a testament to Paranormal Pizza’s skill in vegan cuisine. The cheese, crafted from cashews, offers a creamy, melty experience that rivals traditional dairy—delighting even the skeptical taste buds. The dough and sauce strike a perfect balance, forming a sturdy yet tender base that carries the toppings flawlessly.

Beyond pizza, Paranormal Pizza shines with inventive sides and sandwiches like the beloved pork-less sandwich and cheese steaks. The garlic parm wings paired with ranch dressing have garnered a loyal fanbase, praised for their flavor depth and satisfying crunch. The Detroit-style pie is also a popular choice, offering a thick, crispy crust that holds a generous load of toppings.

What stands out most is the restaurant's commitment to quality and customer experience. The friendly staff, inviting atmosphere, and consistency in flavor keep patrons returning and passionate about the brand. Whether you're a dedicated vegan or simply a lover of well-crafted pizza, Paranormal Pizza offers a compelling, flavorful adventure you won’t soon forget.

Business Information

  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Onsite services
    • Takeout
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards